Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

    Let's see here.

    (BTW, front office, please fix the communications breakdown on the website and update the listed roster with correct positions. We only have FOUR LB's listed, and one of them is playing safety. I accept that cuts were just done, but it might look good to fix this soon.)

    DT: Laurent, Legare, Reid. Rotation of three. Okay.
    DE: Peach, Sykes, Sewell. Rotation of three. Also okay.

    IIRC normal to dress 6 DL, so we should be good there.

    LB:
    Roster: Hill, Munoz, Davis, Cornell
    Depth chart: Lopez, Davis, Cornell, Munoz, Sharun, Bonner, Miller

    7 guys for 4 spots. Okay, I guess. But it doesn't make sense when...

    DB:
    Roster: Alexander, Bonner, Brown, Lopez, Miller, Pittman, Sharun, Thompson, Williams
    Depth chart: Alexander, Thompson, Williams, Hill, Brown

    Five guys for five positions and zero DB depth whatsoever (unless we're moving LB's back, which is possible).


    Regardless, two points to be made here:

    1) List players under correct positions because it makes a lot more sense then.
    2) Our roster balance looks extremely out of whack right now in the back nine (or eight). 12 guys dressed to cover nine positions is okay, but I can't see all that many of those kid LB's dropping back into the secondary and doing well. Harris was probably the best cover LB we had and he's gone. Depth issues.



    Also. TEN receivers to cover six positions (or seven, if one includes KR).

    Seems a bit much, no?. 1/4 of the roster, nearly, is receivers? I have no doubt we'll sit one or two when we make the 42...but still.


    As of right now, we have to sit one import (a receiver, or Duval), and three NI's (one or two receivers, either Fils or Messam, and maybe a backup LB...but we only have 12 guys for 9 positions as it is).
    We could sit 2 imports (two receivers and have a KR as a receiver also) and 2 NI's (RB and REC), too, but that might not help.


    Interesting stuff, regardless. I hope everything works out...but man do we have a lot of rookies on defence.
    We're cheering Fight Fight Fight On Eskimos...

    #2
    Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

    Do any of the receivers have experience playing in the secondary?? Otherwise I guess it means guys who are not good enough for other teams will be starters on the Esks...

    Comment


      #3
      Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

      Originally posted by Party Time View Post
      Do any of the receivers have experience playing in the secondary?? Otherwise I guess it means guys who are not good enough for other teams will be starters on the Esks...
      It's funny...almost all the retreads back there are gone.

      I think the only one left is Alexander at present...and he might not fit the traditional definition as IIRC he was a straight FA and wasn't cut (though I could be wrong).

      That being said...we're throwing a lot of rookies into what looks like a very complicated scheme. Will it work? We'll see. But judging by the ease teams are having throwing over the top of us, I'm not filled with confidence at the moment.
      We're cheering Fight Fight Fight On Eskimos...

      Comment


        #4
        Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

        Originally posted by gizmo fan 2 View Post
        It's funny...almost all the retreads back there are gone.

        I think the only one left is Alexander at present...and he might not fit the traditional definition as IIRC he was a straight FA and wasn't cut (though I could be wrong).

        That being said...we're throwing a lot of rookies into what looks like a very complicated scheme. Will it work? We'll see. But judging by the ease teams are having throwing over the top of us, I'm not filled with confidence at the moment.
        we have to believe stubler knows what he is doing..
        either that or we will be trading alot with toronto in the next 24 hours

        Comment


          #5
          Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

          I really don't like the idea of any of the lb's dropping back to play safety even as depth.. I'm still not sold on Hill back there in fact. I think he's too slow to cover as much ground as Stublers scheme needs him to. I think this is part of why we keep getting beat over the top.
          The only place success comes before work is in the dictionary.

          Vince Lombardi

          Comment


            #6
            Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

            ^ TJ is doing a great job, I am sold that he will be able to continue to adjust, Dickenson targeted Walls (and tested TJ, for sure). However, watching the game the biggest issue for me, is the adjustment and communication with the lbs and dbs. Something is not clicking yet in with the LB's which would change immediately if TJ moved to LB. It is definitely an option to consider.

            Comment


              #7
              Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

              I've long since given up on trying to figure out what the 'plan' is as far as personell on this team.

              Comment


                #8
                Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

                Red Dog

                Who are the Esks going to play at MB with Davis now that they cut Cuthberson? Bonner with Hill outside?

                Then who is at safety?

                Not sure if Cuthberson was good enough or not, but why they cut Harris and Walls makes no sense to me

                Comment


                  #9
                  Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

                  meant MLB not MB

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

                    Originally posted by mattdunigan View Post
                    Red Dog

                    Who are the Esks going to play at MB with Davis now that they cut Cuthberson? Bonner with Hill outside?

                    Then who is at safety?

                    Not sure if Cuthberson was good enough or not, but why they cut Harris and Walls makes no sense to me
                    Maybe ET figures if we are going to be lousy then we may as well be cheap???

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

                      Originally posted by mattdunigan View Post
                      Red Dog

                      Who are the Esks going to play at MLB with Davis now that they cut Culberson? Bonner with Hill outside?

                      Then who is at safety?

                      Not sure if Culberson was good enough or not, but why they cut Harris and Walls makes no sense to me
                      Lopez will back up Alexander and should do ok. Bonner will back up at safety as that was his natural position in college.

                      I think we will be ok we just need to replace Legare.
                      Run the Ball up the gut around the horn it does not matter. We run we win what is so difficult to understand.

                      Comment


                        #12
                        Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

                        Dan

                        that still doesn't explain who will be the stating lb's? Munoz at WILL, Davis at MLB, who is the other MLB and who is the Sam with Cuthberson and Harris out?

                        Comment


                          #13
                          Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

                          Originally posted by mattdunigan View Post
                          Dan

                          that still doesn't explain who will be the stating lb's? Munoz at WILL, Davis at MLB, who is the other MLB and who is the Sam with Cuthberson and Harris out?
                          Guess we trade for one?

                          Comment


                            #14
                            Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

                            Originally posted by Beerfish View Post
                            I've long since given up on trying to figure out what the 'plan' is as far as personell on this team.
                            I really don't believe there is one.
                            WALTER IS MY HERO!!

                            Comment


                              #15
                              Re: Roster balance - who's where on defence? And we have how many REC?

                              Id love to see byron bullock the guy the riders cut brought in here or chris graham either one

                              Comment

                              Working...
                              X