Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

No Iron on Iron for Esks? How do we improve the tackling then?

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    No Iron on Iron for Esks? How do we improve the tackling then?

    So for me the most frustrating thing is seeing our D guys try and tackle guys by shoulder checking them and all of the other sloppy tackling I see. I think we have the worst tackling team in the league.

    So what can be done about it? I've listened to interviews from Reed and he pretty much says that it is impossible to practice tackling. I've heard him say this on the radio. I just listened to him again and he pretty much goes into again and gives some reasons like the low roster size, cba rules, you just can't do it, etc...

    1. The low roster size. Ok I get this reason. If they were to go full out at practice and guys get injured then all of us would be up in arms over it. Hell, they aren't practicing tackling at full speed and STILL Grymes gets hurt.

    2. CBA rule. I'll admit i'm ignorant on this part and I don't know if full contact is limited or banned in the cba or the other provisions related to this part of practice.

    3. I really think that Reed just doesn't want to have them practice tackling and just admits to himself that it's not possible to do it.

    Ok, I have an interesting article: http://www.torontosun.com/2013/08/03...elers-practice

    It's worth a read. I get that the Steelers have a much bigger roster size and more advantages that a CFL team will not have so maybe they can get away with full on contact drills. Let's face it the Steelers are known as one of the tougher teams in the NFL and they have the type of reputation the Esks used to have... a nasty one.

    Even saying all of this every CFL team operates under the same rules so why do we have the worst tackling team? Is it just a case of having players with a tough mindset who want to go out there and beat someone up rather than "finesse" the opponent? It seems like our tackling on D is getting worse year on year under Kavis.

    I'm just frustrated with the D and especially Marshall. He's been a disaster for the D and this team.
    2015 EsksFans CFL Pool Winner

    #2
    Re: No Iron on Iron for Esks? How do we improve the tackling then?

    From what I remember of this CBA, the team is allowed 12 full contact practices a season. Twelve. Total. Now that's across the League so it still doesn't excuse the Esks from crappy tackling, since all the other teams seems to be able to do it. Now, should they be doing some more fundamental training? You'd hope that by this level they'd know how to tackle...it's sort of like a receiver not knowing the fundamentals of catching a fuc&ing football. No reason for it.
    Once an Eskimo, ALWAYS an Eskimo.

    Comment


      #3
      Re: No Iron on Iron for Esks? How do we improve the tackling then?

      I'm going to listen to the KR Show on Ched at 8 tonight, but not really expecting a lot of meaty questions from Shill Campbell or any meaningful responses from Reed himself. Hoping that someone has the balls to call in and query Reed about the absolutely horrible defence being coached by Greg Marshall and how long of a leash he'll be on going forward.

      Comment


        #4
        Re: No Iron on Iron for Esks? How do we improve the tackling then?

        "Football comes down to blocking and tackling. The best teams are the best at that" - Chris Morris (University of Alberta Golden Bears Coach)

        Inside Sports, 630 ched, Aug 19, 2013, 19:40.
        Last edited by Esks1949; 08-19-2013, 07:42 PM. Reason: golden bears coach
        2015 EsksFans CFL Pool Winner

        Comment


          #5
          Re: No Iron on Iron for Esks? How do we improve the tackling then?

          Originally posted by boydo View Post
          From what I remember of this CBA, the team is allowed 12 full contact practices a season. Twelve. Total. Now that's across the League so it still doesn't excuse the Esks from crappy tackling, since all the other teams seems to be able to do it. Now, should they be doing some more fundamental training? You'd hope that by this level they'd know how to tackle...it's sort of like a receiver not knowing the fundamentals of catching a fuc&ing football. No reason for it.
          Huh... only 12 games. That's crazy. Maybe as coach you keep 1 or two days for later in the season so when the tackling starts to drop off you have a full contact practice. Don't want to tackle in the game, then tackle in practice. Kind of like the football equivalent of the bag skate in hockey.
          2015 EsksFans CFL Pool Winner

          Comment


            #6
            Re: No Iron on Iron for Esks? How do we improve the tackling then?

            Why don't we just replace Munoz that would improve team tackling dramatically we could put a scarecrow out there he might be in the right lane to trip someone up once in a while which would still be an improvement.
            In Rod we trust

            Comment


              #7
              Re: No Iron on Iron for Esks? How do we improve the tackling then?

              Originally posted by tigerdar View Post
              Why don't we just replace Munoz that would improve team tackling dramatically we could put a scarecrow out there he might be in the right lane to trip someone up once in a while which would still be an improvement.
              Then we'd get nothing but tripping penalties though...
              Once an Eskimo, ALWAYS an Eskimo.

              Comment


                #8
                Re: No Iron on Iron for Esks? How do we improve the tackling then?

                perhaps players should stop going for the highlight real tackles and just wrap the man up.

                Comment


                  #9
                  Re: No Iron on Iron for Esks? How do we improve the tackling then?

                  Originally posted by boydo View Post
                  Then we'd get nothing but tripping penalties though...
                  Nah CFL refs can't recognize PI I doubt they can recognize tripping
                  In Rod we trust

                  Comment


                    #10
                    Re: No Iron on Iron for Esks? How do we improve the tackling then?

                    Originally posted by tigerdar View Post
                    Nah CFL refs can't recognize PI I doubt they can recognize tripping
                    Thought we got one last game...
                    Maybe it was another game, but definitely a tripping penalty was handed out this last weekend...
                    Once an Eskimo, ALWAYS an Eskimo.

                    Comment


                      #11
                      Re: No Iron on Iron for Esks? How do we improve the tackling then?

                      Originally posted by tigerdar View Post
                      Nah CFL refs can't recognize PI I doubt they can recognize tripping
                      They don't. Ask Keith Shologan.
                      Originally posted by Diesel
                      Stop living in the past. They aren't champs this year.
                      Originally posted by griswold
                      Those little footballs are harder to defend against than our offence.

                      Comment

                      Working...
                      X