Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Riders/Stamps GDT

Collapse
X
Collapse
 
  • Page of 7
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 template Next
    #31
    Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

    Originally posted by MoneyGuy View Post
    Was the right call made on he fumbled kick return? Lysack booted it into the endzone, but does it change the call because it was unintentional? I believe the correct call was made.
    I also believe the correct call was made. I doubt that the intention of the person whos foot the ball goes off matters in how the play is ruled.

    i need to figure out my money situation!!
    Originally posted by Diesel
    Stop living in the past. They aren't champs this year.
    Originally posted by griswold
    Those little footballs are harder to defend against than our offence.

    Comment

      #32
      Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

      What really hurts about the Riders winning is that Warren Kean will be kicking in the Grey Cup in our house and in our dressing room. OMG

      Comment

        #33
        Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

        Originally posted by MoneyGuy View Post
        Was the right call made on he fumbled kick return? Lysack booted it into the endzone, but does it change the call because it was unintentional? I believe the correct call was made.
        I believe the kicking only comes into play if the ball is kicked out of bounds. Because a Calgary player was the last to touch the ball and "batted" it into the end zone and a Saskatchewan player recovered the ball in the end zone, by rule the Riders then get the ball on their own 25 yard line and there are no points scored.

        However, if a Saskatchewan player had batted the ball from the field of play into the end zone and then a Saskatchewan player recovered the ball it would have been a two point "safety touch" and the Riders would have had to kick the ball off to the Stamps from their own 35 yard line. So, yes, the correct call was made on that one.
        Maciocia, Hall, Strasser, Hairston and Thorpe are finally all gone. The rest will take care of itself.

        Good luck Kavis Reed and the rest of the Esks' new coaching staff!

        Comment

          #34
          Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

          I believe that it was very close on the fumble. It is tough to tell if his forearm was down before the ball was out. I would have felt that there was not enough evidence to overturn. On the one replay iot looked like there was green between his forearm and the ground (no it was not a sleeve) when he started to lose the ball. On another it looked like his arm was on the ground first. Once again a tough call.

          I am surprised on the punt that no point was awarded. The ball went into the endzone, I would think that it should have at least been a single.

          I am happy the Browner and Bryant`s actions cost their team dearly. Bryant took them out of feildgoal (sack did took them out more, but a shorted gain on Second down would have got them back in range) range and Browner gave the Riders extra downs in the red zone, one of which they pounded in for a TD.

          Regina will not be as busy this weekend now people will trying to be going to Edmonton, rather then Agribition (a bunch of farmers on icy city roads is not fun)
          "Beer is proof that God loves us and wants us to be happy."

          "The only thing I ever feared was failure" - Dan Kepley

          Comment

            #35
            Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

            Anyways....

            I'm happy the Riders beat the Stamps! I did not want Calgary in our EE New Players Room (dressing room) period! They are not worthy!

            And Rotor.... I'm pulling for Sask next weekend because of the above statement....go riders go!

            Comment

              #36
              Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

              Originally posted by JoeyJoJoJr View Post
              i need to figure out my money situation!!
              You called?

              Comment

                #37
                Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

                On the Wes Cates fumble, the call of the field was a fumble and a Calgary recovery, therefore Calgary's ball. The rule reads that upon review there has to be "conclusive evidence" to overturn the call that is made on the field. I have looked at the replay on PVR about a dozen times and, as objectively as I can, I really can't tell if either his forearm and/or his knee were down before the ball comes out. From one of the angles they show, his forearm and his knee are NOT down before the ball comes out. To me, that is not "conclusive evidence" and the call on the field should have stood.
                Maciocia, Hall, Strasser, Hairston and Thorpe are finally all gone. The rest will take care of itself.

                Good luck Kavis Reed and the rest of the Esks' new coaching staff!

                Comment

                  #38
                  Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

                  Originally posted by budha View Post
                  (a bunch of farmers on icy city roads is not fun)
                  A bunch of farmers, liquored up on Pil, on icy provincial highways is not much fun either.
                  Maciocia, Hall, Strasser, Hairston and Thorpe are finally all gone. The rest will take care of itself.

                  Good luck Kavis Reed and the rest of the Esks' new coaching staff!

                  Comment

                    #39
                    Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

                    Originally posted by turftoe27 View Post
                    What really hurts about the Riders winning is that Warren Kean will be kicking in the Grey Cup in our house and in our dressing room. OMG
                    Who is the home team this year - east or west - because I believe the home team gets their choice of dressing rooms.
                    Maciocia, Hall, Strasser, Hairston and Thorpe are finally all gone. The rest will take care of itself.

                    Good luck Kavis Reed and the rest of the Esks' new coaching staff!

                    Comment

                      #40
                      Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

                      Originally posted by MoneyGuy View Post
                      You called?
                      I have a serious want to head to Edmonton for the GC. Can you help me out?
                      Originally posted by Diesel
                      Stop living in the past. They aren't champs this year.
                      Originally posted by griswold
                      Those little footballs are harder to defend against than our offence.

                      Comment

                        #41
                        Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

                        Originally posted by JoeyJoJoJr View Post
                        I have a serious want to head to Edmonton for the GC. Can you help me out?
                        Sure. You can stay at his place.
                        Maciocia, Hall, Strasser, Hairston and Thorpe are finally all gone. The rest will take care of itself.

                        Good luck Kavis Reed and the rest of the Esks' new coaching staff!

                        Comment

                          #42
                          Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

                          Originally posted by Old Caretaker View Post
                          Wrong.
                          I think it's you who's wrong. They got that one right.
                          "No one entertains the thought that maybe God does not believe in you." - Bo Burnham

                          Comment

                            #43
                            Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

                            Originally posted by JoeyJoJoJr View Post
                            I damn near wet myself there. Could see the end of the game.



                            Actually, you're wrong.

                            I can play this game too, isn't it easy? Go back and look at the thirty replays and make note of the non hand/foot contact with the ground before the ball comes out.
                            Of course you think he's wrong, you cheer for the team that benefitted from the blown call.

                            I have a 50" HD TV and watched EVERY replay and there was no conclusive evidence ANYWHERE that he was down before it came out. And since the call on the field was fumble......the replay booth ****ed up. You can play whatever games you want, check the footage, it was a fumble.
                            Originally posted by Traxy
                            If his moral character isn't good enough for the goddamn Saskatchewan Roughriders, it sure as hell isn't good enough for the Green and Gold.
                            Interesting that it was the Riders who moaned and bitched for a salary cap, and since a cap was put in place for them, they only years they've won they broke the salary cap rules.

                            Comment

                              #44
                              Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

                              Originally posted by MoneyGuy View Post
                              Was the right call made on he fumbled kick return? Lysack booted it into the endzone, but does it change the call because it was unintentional? I believe the correct call was made.
                              Not sure about that one, but if the right call was made on the fumble, the ball gets turned over and it's 16-13 Stamps. So the endzone call was more or less irrelevant.
                              Originally posted by Traxy
                              If his moral character isn't good enough for the goddamn Saskatchewan Roughriders, it sure as hell isn't good enough for the Green and Gold.
                              Interesting that it was the Riders who moaned and bitched for a salary cap, and since a cap was put in place for them, they only years they've won they broke the salary cap rules.

                              Comment

                                #45
                                Re: Riders/Stamps GDT

                                Originally posted by griswold View Post
                                Of course you think he's wrong, you cheer for the team that benefitted from the blown call.

                                I have a 50" HD TV and watched EVERY replay and there was no conclusive evidence ANYWHERE that he was down before it came out. And since the call on the field was fumble......the replay booth ****ed up. You can play whatever games you want, check the footage, it was a fumble.
                                Pot, meet kettle.

                                You are the most biased anti-Rider poster I know. Your opinion carries little weight in my book.
                                "No one entertains the thought that maybe God does not believe in you." - Bo Burnham

                                Comment

                                Previous 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 template Next
                                Working...
                                X