Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

2023-2024 off-season

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

    Originally posted by Looner View Post

    It was driven by the players for sure and I'm not saying they do away with it completely but they need to tweak it for sure as it makes it harder to turn a team around
    What one would hope is its existence causes teams to make smarter hiring decisions in the first place as opposed to bad decisions they can simply fire their way out of at the drop of a hat.

    The thing with the FOPs cap is it's not a hard cap but everybody talks about it like it's a brick wall. It's a soft cap. In the grand scheme of turning a franchise around the penalties are not overly debilitating. Up to $100K over costs $1 per $1 over. For any amount over $100K penalties range from $25K fine plus loss of one 2nd rd pick to a max of $250K and loss of 3 draft picks. If a team chooses to hold firm and not cross the line it would hurt. However they could also accept the penalties, leverage the mulligan and move on as close to business as usual as possible.

    Comment


      Originally posted by Hammer24 View Post

      What one would hope is its existence causes teams to make smarter hiring decisions in the first place as opposed to bad decisions they can simply fire their way out of at the drop of a hat.

      The thing with the FOPs cap is it's not a hard cap but everybody talks about it like it's a brick wall. It's a soft cap. In the grand scheme of turning a franchise around the penalties are not overly debilitating. Up to $100K over costs $1 per $1 over. For any amount over $100K penalties range from $25K fine plus loss of one 2nd rd pick to a max of $250K and loss of 3 draft picks. If a team chooses to hold firm and not cross the line it would hurt. However they could also accept the penalties, leverage the mulligan and move on as close to business as usual as possible.
      Fair enough. Unfortunately though teams that are likely in this position are in a lower revenue period making it harder to absorb those penalties. $350K on top of the sunk costs and 3 draft picks is quite a penalty for a team going through a bad time financially especially as they are likely a team that has a greater need to find guys through the draft.

      Seeing this though, I can't see why a team like Saskatchewan would ever be afraid of the penalties, but Edmonton has been bleeding out financially since Covid so I can see this as quite a deterrent. I suspect Ottawa has been as well.

      Comment


        I guess according to some reporters out there Tre Ford is as good as gone despite objections to the contrary by CJ and GS. Wonder if TF actually was on the trading block early last season for a first round pick as the rumor mill mentioned in the article professess...https://3downnation.com/2024/03/21/e...d-chris-jones/
        Last edited by adb; 03-21-2024, 12:47 PM.
        “RUN THE DANG BALL!" -Leigh Anne Tuohy character from the film The Blind Side

        "Next time, take a case of Pil into the huddle. If you don't get a beer, get the hell off the field!" -New special teams coach for the Riders

        "When the Eskimos are out on defense it looks like there are two or three number 47s out there." -Duane Ford

        "...I guess we'll have to agree to disagree, I enjoy the banter though ..." -Looner

        Comment


          Originally posted by adb View Post
          I guess according to some reporters out there Tre Ford is as good as gone. Wonder if he actually was on the trading block early last season for a first round pick as the rumor mill mentioned in the article professess...https://3downnation.com/2024/03/21/e...d-chris-jones/
          Reporters going to sensationalize this as long as they can. Though this one isn't too bad about it. Reality is that we have no idea how this year will play out yet, and no one with the team has suggested anything other than them wanting him to work with MBT this year to become a better QB. Ford hasn't publicly stated anything suggesting he's going to be a problem only the stuff you'd expect where he's saying he's going to go in there thinking like a starter and competing for the ball, which you wouldn't want to hear otherwise.

          As such, let's just see how this plays out. All kinds of scenarios could still play out including ones where Ford is pushed into the starters role and ends up playing terribly. I wouldn't bet against the kid, but truth is this league is littered with young QBs that come in and look awesome taking over for a portion of a season, and eventually fizzing out. I find it interesting that people suggest Jones should have bet his last chance to continue being a GM and HC in the league on someone that this could possibly happen

          Especially when he may have been on his way out regardless of how this year went. I was always puzzled by stories of him going out for dinner by himself after a victory instead of going with teammates. I appreciate the kid doesn't drink or want to be around excessive partying, but I suspect there were ways to celebrate as a team without him drinking and without the party turning into a gong show.

          Comment


            Originally posted by Hammer24 View Post

            Problem is without the FOPs cap any team doing very well financially will be setting the bar for the rest, whether they can afford it or not. Spending money never guarantees success but if one team wants to spend like drunken sailors on FOPs the rest have little choice but to try to "keep up with the Joneses". I hate using that idiom give Chris Jones is a GM but it fits.

            By having a FOPs cap they are leveling the playing field and placing a governor on a high spending team's ability to go raiding other staffs for top assistants. See a young up and coming coordinator or positional assistent you like? Go offer him a spot, tweak the job title to turn it into a faux-promotion and give him an extra $100K and boom he's gone.

            While you seem to be placing the blame for the FOPs cap solely on the feet of the league there is another major player in its creation you are totally overlooking. A very big proponent of the concept was the CFLPA. They were sitting their living under the SMS cap system. They stood up and said "hey wait a minute. We're working under a cap that limits spending on salaries and the number of jobs available while there are no controls on the number of people teams have in their football ops or how much can be spent on them?!?!? WTF?!?!?" They could see how coaching staffs were growing unchecked and started wondering how long before they were NFL sized staffs. No doubt the players wondered if the growth and spend trends on FOPs staff continued how much would be coming at their expense.

            I firmly believe that if the CFL tried to do away with the FOPs cap they would receive a ton of pushback from the CFLPA. In the meantime it will stay until there is consensus amongst the 9 governors that it's no longer necessary or needs major tweaks. Having said that I could see maybe a tweak to allow amortization of cap hit for fired coaches to be spread out a bit more.
            You guys keep missing the point of my response and I am not sure how else to say it.

            If the league or players want the Ops cap to keep costs in line then keep it.

            What I have said and keep saying is, they should not have the salary of people who get fired from their job count against the cap next season.

            How the OPs cap works by my understanding is you have a set number that all your operations people and coaches have to fall under. For complete ease of the conversation, the pretend number is $1000. (YES I KNOW IT'S WAY MORE. SAYING 1000 IS JUST FOR EASE OF MY CONVERSATION).

            I don't pretend to know who all falls under the cap but for my purpose I am listing. Pres, GM, AGM, HC, DC, OC, ST. I know there are more but to save time and words, I just picked those names because it's easy and you don't need every single guy to make my point.

            Year 1 -The league says the yearly Ops cap is $1000 for every team. Team X is paying the following guys who count for the ops cap:

            Pres - $200
            GM - $175
            HC - $150
            AGM - $125
            OC - $125
            DC - $125
            ST - $100

            Equals 1000

            All those guys get signed for 2 years.

            The season doesn't go well, players hate the HC, he gets fired after 1 season. There would technically be 1 year left on his deal but he's fired. He's coaching some Highschool team in the US.


            Year 2 -The league says the yearly Ops cap is $1000 for every team.

            $1000

            - CFL says, you fired your coach last year and even though he is coaching a Texas Highschool this year, he technically had 1 yr left so you have to count that against your Ops cap.

            $1000 - $150 (from the fired HC) = $850.

            So for year 2, they only have $850 to work with, instead of the $1000 because the coach that was lousy at his job and got fired, had a year left on his deal. So even though he's no longer working in the league, the team has to account for it.


            So like I said, how does it make any sense to penalize a team for firing a guy by making them keep his cap hit when he's no longer with the team? IMO, if a person is no longer employed by the team, his salary should not count against the cap.

            So to your point. If a team wants to spend like a drunken sailor on some hot shot coach, go right ahead. But his salary has to come under the cap just like everyone else. So for my example, if a team wants to give one coach $500 of the $1000 available, they can do that. But they just have to find other ways to cut costs. So maybe that means 1 guy has to do what Jones was and have 3 jobs but again, if that guy gets fired, his salary should not count against the teams future cap when he's not working for the team.


            Blindly accept whatever they do and if it doesn't work out, I guess there's always next year.

            Comment


              One quick note Q. Most Club Presidents like Vienneau on BC, LeLacheur, Reynolds or Miller in Winnipeg would not be part of the equation. They are Business Ops people whose FOPs involvement might begin and end with participating in hiring the GM who is typically the top of the FOPs food chain. Exceptions would be someone like Steinauer who is President of FOPs reporting to Club CEO Scott Mitchell and Club President and COO Matt Afinec.
              Last edited by Hammer24; 03-21-2024, 03:57 PM.

              Comment


                Originally posted by Sectionq View Post

                You guys keep missing the point of my response and I am not sure how else to say it.

                If the league or players want the Ops cap to keep costs in line then keep it.

                What I have said and keep saying is, they should not have the salary of people who get fired from their job count against the cap next season.

                How the OPs cap works by my understanding is you have a set number that all your operations people and coaches have to fall under. For complete ease of the conversation, the pretend number is $1000. (YES I KNOW IT'S WAY MORE. SAYING 1000 IS JUST FOR EASE OF MY CONVERSATION).

                I don't pretend to know who all falls under the cap but for my purpose I am listing. Pres, GM, AGM, HC, DC, OC, ST. I know there are more but to save time and words, I just picked those names because it's easy and you don't need every single guy to make my point.

                Year 1 -The league says the yearly Ops cap is $1000 for every team. Team X is paying the following guys who count for the ops cap:

                Pres - $200
                GM - $175
                HC - $150
                AGM - $125
                OC - $125
                DC - $125
                ST - $100

                Equals 1000

                All those guys get signed for 2 years.

                The season doesn't go well, players hate the HC, he gets fired after 1 season. There would technically be 1 year left on his deal but he's fired. He's coaching some Highschool team in the US.


                Year 2 -The league says the yearly Ops cap is $1000 for every team.

                $1000

                - CFL says, you fired your coach last year and even though he is coaching a Texas Highschool this year, he technically had 1 yr left so you have to count that against your Ops cap.

                $1000 - $150 (from the fired HC) = $850.

                So for year 2, they only have $850 to work with, instead of the $1000 because the coach that was lousy at his job and got fired, had a year left on his deal. So even though he's no longer working in the league, the team has to account for it.


                So like I said, how does it make any sense to penalize a team for firing a guy by making them keep his cap hit when he's no longer with the team? IMO, if a person is no longer employed by the team, his salary should not count against the cap.

                So to your point. If a team wants to spend like a drunken sailor on some hot shot coach, go right ahead. But his salary has to come under the cap just like everyone else. So for my example, if a team wants to give one coach $500 of the $1000 available, they can do that. But they just have to find other ways to cut costs. So maybe that means 1 guy has to do what Jones was and have 3 jobs but again, if that guy gets fired, his salary should not count against the teams future cap when he's not working for the team.

                To use you ratio formula and apply it to the FOPs cap it would work out to:

                Pres - $500K
                GM - $437.5K
                HC - $375K
                AGM - $312.5K
                OC - $312.5K
                DC - $312.5K
                ST - $250K

                Depending on position I think those salaries would be at least 10% high to pushing 40% toàay 50% high on things like AGM and the coordinators. On your ratio formula $40 would be average salary if a team had the max 11 coaches and 14 other FOPs personnel. Under the actual cap the average is $100K. Now it's definitely true that the positions you listed will be compensated above the mean average but a lot of other positions like scouts, entry level positional coaches, equipment staff and video personnel are not making the mean average. Some of those lower level jobs are seasonal.

                Of course experience plays a role. First time coaches in any role will not be making as much as veterans with many years in the same role. In the end the GM's job is to make it all fit within the confines of the $2.5M for 25 positions not unlike having to make the player salaries fit under the SMS. In both cases it's a jigsaw puzzle.

                Comment


                  Originally posted by Hammer24 View Post

                  To use you ratio formula and apply it to the FOPs cap it would work out to:

                  Pres - $500K
                  GM - $437.5K
                  HC - $375K
                  AGM - $312.5K
                  OC - $312.5K
                  DC - $312.5K
                  ST - $250K

                  Depending on position I think those salaries would be at least 10% high to pushing 40% toàay 50% high on things like AGM and the coordinators. On your ratio formula $40 would be average salary if a team had the max 11 coaches and 14 other FOPs personnel. Under the actual cap the average is $100K. Now it's definitely true that the positions you listed will be compensated above the mean average but a lot of other positions like scouts, entry level positional coaches, equipment staff and video personnel are not making the mean average. Some of those lower level jobs are seasonal.

                  Of course experience plays a role. First time coaches in any role will not be making as much as veterans with many years in the same role. In the end the GM's job is to make it all fit within the confines of the $2.5M for 25 positions not unlike having to make the player salaries fit under the SMS. In both cases it's a jigsaw puzzle.
                  When is someone going to bend the rules by giving dual roles to a coach, with one being vice president where a bunch of his salary will sit.

                  Comment


                    Originally posted by Looner View Post

                    When is someone going to bend the rules by giving dual roles to a coach, with one being vice president where a bunch of his salary will sit.
                    I don't think titles mean much at all. Regardless of job titles if duties of the dual roles are both football operations duties then the salary(s) will fall under the FOPs cap. Generally it's fairly easy to distinguish between those who are involved with football ops versus business ops. The league office should easily see right through any hanky panky of trying to stash a FOPs person under the BOPs umbrella. And if they can't see it no doubt another club will bring it to their attention.
                    Last edited by Hammer24; 03-22-2024, 01:39 PM.

                    Comment


                      https://www.cfl.ca/2024/03/23/we-ask...-the-no-1-pick

                      So this is interesting. The speculation about what Jones will do is enough, but then you get to Jim Barker’s comment that Gittens is hurt and is likely to be six-gamed to start the season. What?

                      You trade your best defensive player who is one of your only all-stars for a guy who may not be ready to go in Year 1, but is due a similar paycheque? I want to like this trade and the theory behind it, but we need confidence he’s going to be on the field.

                      Comment


                        [QUOTE=BeaverSports;n1279456]https://www.cfl.ca/2024/03/23/we-ask...-the-no-1-pick

                        So this is interesting. The speculation about what Jones will do is enough, but then you get to Jim Barker’s comment that Gittens is hurt and is likely to be six-gamed to start the season. What?

                        Yes, I read that too and did a head shake. Then I realized the comment was made by Barker ; not a guy I view as really connected with what is happening currently and occasionally even with reality. He just needed to say “something” . I ‘ll wait for credible verification.

                        Comment


                          I think I got a good idea of our starters for all position groups…. Other then DL…

                          Can someone let me know who they think will be our 2 DE and 2 DT…..
                          My guess is one DE is Brown… seemed to get better last year and CJ seemed to like him…

                          Pelly as a National Starter at DT…. Has shown promise… but seemed hurt or banged up much of last season…

                          Nkemdichie…. High NFL draft pick… sure he didn’t sign a low price contract to come to CFL…

                          What say you?

                          Comment


                            what KGJ is injured? Geez

                            Comment


                              Originally posted by SKIP12 View Post
                              I think I got a good idea of our starters for all position groups…. Other then DL…

                              Can someone let me know who they think will be our 2 DE and 2 DT…..
                              My guess is one DE is Brown… seemed to get better last year and CJ seemed to like him…

                              Pelly as a National Starter at DT…. Has shown promise… but seemed hurt or banged up much of last season…

                              Nkemdichie…. High NFL draft pick… sure he didn’t sign a low price contract to come to CFL…

                              What say you?
                              There's a lot of competition there. I could see it being Curtis, Acheampong, Pelley, and maybe Brown, but you never know with all the new bodies.

                              Comment


                                [QUOTE=couchspud;n1279457]
                                Originally posted by BeaverSports View Post
                                https://www.cfl.ca/2024/03/23/we-ask...-the-no-1-pick

                                So this is interesting. The speculation about what Jones will do is enough, but then you get to Jim Barker’s comment that Gittens is hurt and is likely to be six-gamed to start the season. What?

                                Yes, I read that too and did a head shake. Then I realized the comment was made by Barker ; not a guy I view as really connected with what is happening currently and occasionally even with reality. He just needed to say “something” . I ‘ll wait for credible verification.
                                Gittens was hurt on September 9th and was done for the season. He is still recovering from what sounds like a serious hip injury. He's hoping to be ready for training camp per the Jan 12th article in the link. Ironically that was 3 days before the trade indicating Jones went made the trade with eyes wide open. Obviously being 100% by training camp is not guaranteed but with 2 months having passed since the article they should know if he's ahead of schedule or behind or if there's been any setbacks.

                                Technically, Gittens had suffered an acetabular fracture, a break in the socket portion of the ball and socket hip joint.

                                “I thought I could give it time, it would heal up and I’d be back for the playoffs, but after getting a second opinion from a hip specialist, he said the best route was surgery. My season was done. I didn’t want to do the surgery because it meant my season was done, but getting the surgery was better for my future.”

                                After his not so pleasant birthday present, Gittens was not allowed to put weight on the hip for six weeks, meaning he was under bed rest for a month and a half. After a checkup and a green light from the doctor he was able to go back to BMO Field and attend a practice to give his teammates encouragement before the Eastern Final.

                                In early December he was given the okay to start fully training again. He’s working on his mechanics; running, lifting weights, jumping, squats, “The normal stuff,” according to the receiver.

                                It’s all in attempt to build up strength and mobility and be 100% ready when training camp opens this May in Guelph. Gittens says his recovery is going “Better than the doctor expected.”


                                Hogan: Gittens Rehab Going Well - Toronto Argonauts
                                Last edited by Hammer24; 03-25-2024, 10:11 AM.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X